SCOTUS AM

March 23, 2026 — SCOTUS AM (March Madness Day 1)

Mar 23, 2026
0323 RNC voting March SCOTUS News Update daily AM YT·(TT sequence not listed)
New York Times v. Department of Defense · 25-cv-04218
A federal judge just ordered the Pentagon to let journalists back into the press room. The First Amendment found the door.

The DOD had been blocking journalists who didn't conform to the administration's views from its press briefings. A D.C. district judge ruled that the policy violated the First Amendment — particularly as the country approaches an election, when access to information from multiple perspectives matters most. A prior appeals court ruling had given the executive some discretion over limited press-room space, but this judge found that the Pentagon's viewpoint-based exclusion went too far. The order may be appealed.

Constitutional question: How much control the executive branch has over press access when viewpoint is the sorting criterion — a question the Supreme Court has not yet resolved.
Watson v. Republican National Committee · 24-1260
The Supreme Court is deciding whether a ballot you mailed before Election Day but arrives after still counts — and the answer could change every close election from here on.

Mississippi allows mail-in ballots to be counted if postmarked by Election Day and received within five days after. The RNC sued, arguing a federal law sets a bright-line Election Day deadline that bars counting anything received after that date. The case asks who controls this — Congress or the states — and what Congress actually meant when it set "Election Day." Bryan flags three embedded questions: who's in charge; what does "Election Day" mean as a deadline; and whether cutting off the count actually produces the stability the RNC says it does. He's skeptical — Bush v. Gore gave us chaos without finality; the same argument doesn't hold water just because the rules changed. Justice Thomas's prior states'-rights election-law stance may be tested.

Kagan concurrence: pocketbook injury); disenfranchisement balancing.
Constitutional question: The constitutional divide between state authority to set "time, place, and manner" and Congress's power to set a national election day — a line the Supreme Court has avoided drawing cleanly for over a century.